Friday, October 31, 2008

Endings

I have been characteristically vocal on the Off-Topic forum of Aunt Minnie concerning the upcoming election. I have run up against a fellow nicknamed OutpatientRadRules, a fellow Jew (although nonpracticing) who is rabidly in favor of Mr. Obama becoming President of the United States. ORR's posts took on an increasingly shrill bent:
Funny thing Dalai ---you keep trying to change my vote--I already voted on October 16th---early voting.....Love it! I would appoint Palin for undersecretary of the artic...I think she can see parts of the artic from her living room window! Why is it that die hard consevatives think a vote for a democrat is somehow unpatriotic or unamerican. You sir don't know what democracy is nor do you have any conecpt of what a governemnt is for! As for Israel...have you been there for more than a business trip? Has your family bled and died in '48 or '67--if not then respectfully shut the F up!.....What you know about Israel would then be in my judgement nothing worth the fuzz in between your toes. I served on a kibbutz for a full summer working alongside the Israeli Army, I served guard duty with a gun defending myself and friends so I think I have alot more personal insight to the whole mideast situation than you...I also count palestinians both in and out of Israel my close friends. So don't give me the standard American conservative rant from soemone who sends a check to AIPAC and thinks he supports Israel any more than a fellow colleague with a differnce of opinion. I am fine with Obama and willing to see what happens . . . Israel will not sink into the sea.
In another thread, he even got rather personal, deriding me for my "paunch" as seen in the photo with Robin Williams. Sometimes, enough is enough. I posted the following response:

There are beginnings, and there are endings. This will be the last answer I post to you, Outpatient. Your responses have become increasingly erratic and angry, and even personal. I get enough chiding about my midsection from my wife, thanks. How does that contribute to our discussion to point out my excess poundage? Sadly, I think further discourse with you serves no purpose.

Here are some final musings for you....

I actually do respect you for a number of things. I am proud of you for voting. This is the number one duty of a citizen of a democracy, and yes, I do understand what that means, thank you. My request to you, and to everyone here, is to simply think long and hard before casting that vote. I will assume you did so. I respect you for identifying with the Jewish people, if not our faith. As a Jewish parent, I would be devastated if my children made your choice of one and not both, but I would continue to love them, and in the end, I would have to respect their decision. I respect your service on the Kibbutz, something many other Jewish teens have experienced. I did not have that opportunity, but I hope my children will someday. I have some friends from Syria, though none who are Palestinian. I have no relatives that I know of who fought in any of the Israeli wars. However, about half of my family left Eastern Europe in the early part of the 20th Century and came to America, and the other half perished in the terror of the Holocaust. My outlook is therefore not quite the "standard American Conservative rant". That racial memory, if you will, probably colors my thinking more than any other factor. Clearly, otherwise-rational people can be made to do some very irrational things in the right settings, with the right prompting, and under the influence of the right demagogue.

I have a problem with hero-worship, and voting in lock-step with a particular group, and this is what troubles me most about your innumerable pro-Obama posts. Let me digress. A few years ago, I got into trouble on a website supporting the old Palm Treo 650, one of the first smart-phones. It was introduced with several serious flaws, it crashed, it didn't do much of what it was supposed to do. It did have a much nicer screen than its predecessors, and the blind praise flooded in based on the screen, but ignoring every other problem. I played the "Emperor's New Clothes" game, and pointed out the flaws in this device, and I was soundly trounced by those who only saw what they wanted to see. I think ultimately I was proven correct, although not all would agree. You, too, are seeing only the "pretty screen," Mr. Obama's fine presentation, but choose to ignore what lies beneath. The lavish praise you have heaped upon him is not deserved. Like many members of our tribe, you vote Democratic, assuming with a 50-year-old tradition that they have the best interests of Jews, and Israel, at heart, even when presented with evidence to the contrary. I truly and honestly feel that Mr. Obama is not the best choice for Israel, or for our people. At the very least, there are significant questions about his support for Israel, and for the Palestinian cause, which have not been and will not be answered. We Jews have turned a blind eye to the increasing anti-Semitism manifested by the Left, sometimes blatant, and sometimes masked as anti-Zionism, and we are doing so yet again in this race. What I asked you to do is simply weigh all the evidence, and not march blindly into the voting booth hell-bent on bringing Mr. Obama to power. I can't, and I wouldn't consider controlling your vote. That is yours, it is precious, and it is your right and obligation as a citizen of this nation to vote your conscience.

That's all I have to say about that. I do wish you well in your future endeavours, ORR.


As an aside, I got an email from a non-posting AM reader:

You keep saying Obama isn't what he says he is, and I get the feeling that you are right. Sorry to trouble you, but i've never missed voting in a presidential election and i am agonizing about this. Can you offer any more insight?

I responded with a fairly benign explanation of my views, as per my earlier blog post below. I told him that I assumed he was a legitimate questioner, and not someone looking for ammunition for the AM board. The reader answered:

Yes, I am very legit. Also very confused. I am spiritual in nature but not overly religious, though my beliefs are founded in the bible. I'll stop short of saying that I believe Obama is the Anti-Christ, but the correlation is so overtly clear that it makes my skin crawl. I cannot bring myself to vote for the man. though I admit to being mezmerized when he speaks. Thank you very much, Dr. Dalai. Thank you.

Add to this the post of someone actually trying to chide me...by attributing to me a very well-written and very frightening look backward from the year 2012. This document is obviously written from a Christian perspective, and clearly beyond my meager capabilities. There is some hyperbole, but some of the scenarios ring true enough to scare me to the depths of my being:


(28) Taxes: Tax rates have gone up on personal income, dividends, capital gains, corporations, and inheritance transfers. The amount of income subject to Social Security tax has nearly doubled. The effect on the economy has been devastating. We have experienced a prolonged recession. Everybody has been hurt by this, but the poor have been hurt most of all. In dozens of cities there are just no jobs to be found. It turns out that the people President Obama called “the rich” were mostly not all that rich. They were just ordinary people who worked hard, saved, and built small businesses that provided jobs and brought economic growth. They were the people who kept inventing new and better ways to produce things and bring prices down. They were the people whose companies produced the goods and services that gave us the highest standard of living in history of world. They were the people who provided the competition that kept prices of everything so low. And the top 50% of earners were already paying 97% of income taxes collected by the U.S. government in 2006.

President Obama increased their tax burden so much that many business owners decided they didn’t want to work any harder when the government was taking so much away. “The land of the free?” Not for the most productive workers in the American economy. Just as nearly two million citizens in the decade prior to 2008 had moved out of California and New York when the Democrats had control and kept raising state taxes, many of these entrepreneurs have now moved their money, their factories, and often themselves, overseas. So many jobs have been lost that welfare rolls have swelled, and President Obama is calling for more taxes to meet the needs of those without work.

However, Obama’s tax bill still included “tax credits” for the lowest 40% of earners, who were said to “need the most help.” Since the bottom 40% were not paying any Federal income taxes in the first place, these “tax cuts” were actually a gigantic redistribution of income, a huge welfare payment, a way to “spread the wealth around,” as Obama had told “Joe the Plumber” on October 13, 2008. When critics objected that Obama’s policies were leading to inflation and unemployment, he responded that our goal should not be merely to increase America’s materialism and wealth and prosperity, but to obtain a more just distribution of wealth, even if it costs everybody a little to achieve that important goal.

.....


(25) Israel: “The home of the brave”? In mid-2010 Iran launched a nuclear bomb which exploded in the middle of Tel Aviv, destroying much of that city. They then demanded that Israel cede huge amounts of territory to the Palestinians, and after an anguished all-night cabinet meeting, Israel’s Prime Minister agreed. Israel is now reduced to a much smaller country, hardly able to defend itself, and its future remains uncertain.

President Obama said that he abhorred what Iran had done and he hoped that the UN would unanimously condemn this crime against humanity. He also declared that the U.S. would be part of any international peacekeeping force if authorized by the UN, but the Muslim nations in the UN have so far prevented any UN action.

.....


Many people thought he sounded so thoughtful, so reasonable. And during the campaign, after he had won the Democratic nomination, he seemed to be moving to the center in his speeches, moving away from his earlier far-left record. No one thought he would enact such a far-left, extreme liberal agenda.

But the record was all there for anyone to see. The agenda of the ACLU, the agenda of liberal activist judges in their dissenting opinions, the agenda of the homosexual activists, the agenda of the environmental activists, the agenda of the National Education Association, the agenda of the global warming activists, the agenda of the abortion rights activists, the agenda of the gun control activists, the agenda of the euthanasia supporters, the agenda of the one-world government pacifists, the agenda of far-left groups in Canada and Europe – all of these agendas were there in plain sight, and all of these groups provided huge support for Senator Obama. The liberal agenda was all there. But too many people just didn’t want to see it.

Christians didn’t take time to find out who Barack Obama was when they voted for him. Why did they risk our nation’s future on him? It was a mistake that changed the course of history.

Let's hope this isn't prophetic. Let's hope we don't have to find out.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Politics and PACS

This post represents a shameless theft of an idea from Mike Cannavo, the One and Only PACSMan. However, I'm going to massage it and make it my own.

I have been bantering about the upcoming election with the boys (no girls that I know of) on AuntMinnie.com's Off Topic Forum, for months and months. I had resolved not to bring that discussion to the blog, but frankly, this seems the right time to flip-flop and go ahead with such a post.

As we stand today, one week from the election, Mr. Obama is leading Mr. McCain in the polls. The nation seems intent on believing in Mr. Obama and his mantra of CHANGE, without really delving into just what that means. In many ways, this parallels some of my observations over the years about purchasing PACS.

I have sparred with and against a lot of the guys on AuntMinnie, as well as various PACS companies, PACS administrators, and rads, for a number of years on the board. Believe it or not, I have a lot of respect both my friends and my adversaries in that venue.

I am dismayed at the faith in, and near-worship of, Mr. Obama, just as I worry about the unwarranted confidence placed in some PACS companies. In both cases, these opinions may not be backed up by experience, personal, or on behalf of the candidate. We know very little about Mr. Obama, and we know very little about what he wants. But from every shred of evidence that comes to light, Mr. Obama is in his heart a radical leftist, possibly a socialist, who has learned to hide his leanings behind eloquent speeches and flowery CHANGE and FAIRNESS rhetoric. There are enough hints out there as to what he is all about to make us quite wary. At the very least, there are significant questions that have not been answered beyond Mr. Biden's unsubstantiated denials and subsequent exile of the questioner. Every time Mr. Biden (or Mr. Obama) slips or something new comes to light, it is either suppressed, or the messenger is shot (so far, only figuratively). Mr. Obama has declared his desire for "redistribution of wealth" to Joe the Plumber, and recently unearthed audio tapes show that he was disappointed in the court system for not accomplishing this shift. Mr. Obama is not the man he would like you to think he is. His goals are not in line with mine, and probably not with yours. The "redistribution of wealth" thing is a clue. Consider as well Mr. Obama's statement about selection of jurists: "We need somebody who's got the heart, the empathy, to recognize what it's like to be a young teenage mom. The empathy to understand what it's like to be poor, or African-American, or gay, or disabled, or old. And that's the criteria by which I'm going to be selecting my judges." Translated, the courts should take the side of the plaintiff, especially if they happen to be a minority, and be against "Big Business".

You can call it "hyperbole", you can call it "drama", you can call it "neocon-Zionist rhetoric", but an Obama presidency has the potential to change this nation into something entirely foreign to what we now know and love. THIS POSSIBILITY EXISTS, and laughing about it or denying it doesn't make it go away.

There is a (very) loose parallel between the suspension of rationality concerning Mr. Obama's true motivations and the blind faith many have in some PACS companies. We are told that they have our best interests at heart, that they will CHANGE your enterprise for the better, when in some instances they deliver a reskinned version of the same GUI that didn't work well in the first place. The beautiful display, like eloquent prose, can be very deceiving. But those who vote on such things, who might not be the radiologists, and who might outnumber those radiologists who care, want to believe that this CHANGE is for the better, whether it is or not. They want to hunker down in the belief that LARGE PACS will take care of them, and be the safe choice. Sound familiar?

Politically, we have got to get beyond the Bush presidency. It was a disaster in many ways, but it's almost over. I voted for Mr. Bush twice, and I have no regrets. The alternatives were unacceptable to me and to a lot of other people. We have to make the decision when we step in the booth, and we do the best we can at that moment. But McCain is not Bush. He will not be a perfect President, and he was not my first choice as a candidate, and nor was Mrs. Palin, but I think McCain will do a good job. He deserves your consideration. As I type this, McCain is giving a speech in Pennsylvania. He has finally, in the last weeks of the campaign, matured into a statesman. His delivery is eloquent and powerful, and his words ring true. This man is a hero, a patriot, a man who loves his nation and fought for it. If you parse his words, no hidden meaning comes to light. We cannot say the same for Mr. Obama's equally eloquent but empty speeches.

Again, the similarities to PACS are uncanny. One company might promise to take the maintenance burden off of IT, to "redistribute" the responsibility, so to speak. Another might appeal to the loyalty to a particular product line, and a third might chide the customer for that very same loyalty.

I have had bitter arguments over the years about whether or not a Windows back-end is as good as those written in UNIX or LINUX, digital bigotry, if you will. I can cite instances of someone favoring a system for this reason alone. Mr. McCain has never used the race card, he has never counted on white people to vote for him simply because he is white, and rightly so. Mr. Obama has made numerous oblique references to race, some subtle such as the "historic nature of this election" and "I don't look like those other presidents" for which he is always forgiven. It is clear that 95%+ of African-Americans will vote for him, racially-motivated or not. But somehow, that's OK. I could go on.

I still have significant questions as to why a half-term US Senator skyrocketed to this position. Has anyone ever asked why he was appointed (some would say anointed) to give the keynote address at the 2004 Democratic convention? As near as I can tell, he caught the eye and the ear of John Kerry during the 2004 campaign (Kerry's presidential bid, Obama's senatorial bid) with his wonderful prose. We should realize that Mr. Obama won his election after his Republican opponent, Senator Jack Ryan, became mired in a "sex scandal" and withdrew from the contest. According to the Wikipedia, "People alleged to be Barack Obama's backers emailed reporters about the divorce controversy, but refrained from on-the-record commentary about the divorce files. On March 29, 2004, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Robert Schnider ruled that several of the Ryans' divorce records should be opened to the public," and these records alleged that Ryan took his then wife Jeri (of Star Trek Voyager fame) to sex clubs. Mr. Kerry (and I would assume that Mrs. Heinz-Kerry, a true ultra-liberal, had something to do with this as well) decided that Mr. Obama deserved the national stage. I have to believe at some level that there are a few very wealthy, very powerful liberal folks who have decided for us that it is time for the US to have an African-American, liberal president.

Reflecting on the PACS world, this reminds us of the situation wherein the IT department (or to be fair, the occasional rogue radiologist) decides that System X is the only one that will do, and shoves it through the PACS selection process without proper due diligence on the part of everyone else. Trust me, it happens.

I could rant more, but I'll spare you. All I want to accomplish with this post is to make those of you planning to vote for Mr. Obama think about your choice one more time. I will assume your heart is in the right place, and that you want to do the right thing for your country, your family, and yourself. But please be sure you realize what it is you are voting for. What you see on the surface might not reflect what lies beneath, and what lies are beneath that surface. It's sort of like selecting PACS, except with PACS you can at least demand a web-demo. The flaws in an otherwise slickly-demonstrated GUI might become apparent upon a prolonged test. Unfortunately, our test for a President lasts four years, and there can be a lot of damage done in that time.

Saturday, October 25, 2008

My PACS

You don't want to know the origin of this parody, trust me. . . With apologies to Mickey Avalon....

My PACS has a great low fee
Your PACS uses Pocket PC
My PACS screen is 6MP
Your PACS won’t burn a CD

My PACS holds 10 TB
Your PACS is on a USB
My PACS is faster than lightning
Your PACS is just plain frightening

My PACS is all the rage
Your PACS should get off the stage
My PACS is so hot its melting
Your PACS is awful smelling

My PACS has a real nice GUI
Your PACS is just plain screwy
My PACS has a modern skin
Your PACS looks like the AOL Login

My PACS is supercool
Your PACS can only drool
My PACS covers half the planet
Your PACS just needs to can it

My PACS can sure do that
Your PACS just sits and gets fat
My PACS has a lot of moxy
Your PACS can only work by proxy

[Repeat 2x]
It’s time that we let the world know
Dude, you gotta let film go
My PACS is the best you’ll find
P.S. no one’s got PACS like mine!

My PACS covers every function
Your PACS needs some low grade suction
My PACS serves the enterprise
Your PACS can only theorize

My PACS has a MetroE
Your PACS just plays MP3’s
My PACS has great diagnoses
Your PACS is full of neuroses

My PACS takes 5000 slices
Your PACS just knows how to raise its prices
My PACS is pretty darn swift
Your PACS should be set adrift

My PACS has a fast workstation
Your PACS works like a third-world nation
My PACS is a fine machine
Your PACS needs a shot of caffeine

My PACS can conquer the ocean
Your PACS runs on raw emotion
My PACS never gets in trouble
Your PACS couldn’t see with the Hubble

My PACS is transendental
Your PACS has just gone mental
My PACS is a thundering stallion
Your PACS smells like a scallion

My PACS is nice and easy
Your PACS is pretty sleazy
My PACS is way more than good
Your PACS don’t act like it should

[Repeat 2x]
It’s time that we let the world know
Dude, you gotta let film go
My PACS is the best you’ll find
P.S. no one’s got PACS like mine!

Friday, October 24, 2008

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Exploring PACS Secrets

If you've come to this blog to read about PACS, then you have almost certainly visited AuntMinnie.com as well. Mike Cannavo, the One and Only PACSMan, is about as well-known in the PACS world as Aunt Minnie herself, having been in the business longer than most PACS administrators have been alive.

In 2004, Mike wrote the first installment of "Exploring PACS Secrets," and the series continues today, with the recent publication of "Part XX: Will PACS Survive?" AuntMinnie.com has graciously packaged them all up in a .pdf file available here.

In many ways, I've taken this journey several steps behind Mike (although for a good part of it he didn't even know a thing about this jerk calling himself "Dalai",) having immersed myself in the field pretty heavily beginning in 2003. In rereading the various entries of "Secrets," I am struck first by how prophetic some of the entries have turned out to be, and second by how much more irreverent (and irascible) Mike has become over the years.

This is good reading, people, and you all need to have a look. It's almost as wonderful as Dalai's Laws of PACS! Hey, it's my blog and I can have all the shameless plugs I want!

Monday, October 20, 2008

An Evening With Mork

Every once in a while, it's nice to hang up the white coat (which I don't wear) and ignore PACS and radiology for a few hours. The other week, Robin Williams came to a nearby town. We've been fans for years, so Mrs. Dalai, Dalai, Jr., and I went to see him. For a few bucks more, we got to actually meet him, which was a great experience. Robin's show is non-stop pandemonium and hilarity, and if you get the chance to see him in person, GO! He may be 57, but he has more energy than a nuclear power plant. But be forewarned, the show isn't for the prude or the faint of heart! Fortunately, Dalai, Jr. had heard all those words before. . .

Friday, October 17, 2008

One Hundred Thousand Hits!!!!

What a milestone! From humble beginnings in a log cabin... Wait, wrong story.

Anyway, this evening at 5:51 P.M., someone from Vilnius, Lithuania became visitor 100,000. As it turns out, I have some ancestors from Lithuania, so this landmark is closer to my heart than some. Sadly for my Lithuanian friend, he (or she) was looking for something about LogMeIn, which I mention only briefly in an old post.

I've just renewed the domain "doctordalai.com" for another four years. Let's see if we can get to 1,000,000 visits by then!

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Time for a New PET?

Because of budget constraints, I can't even purchase my SPECT/CT, let alone replace my solid but aging PET/CT. Still, it's always exciting to see what's up and coming in the field.

It seems I should have saved my Euros and gone to the European Association of Nuclear Medicine meeting in Munich instead of the SNM in New Orleans earlier this year. Not one, but two major PET/CT upgrades were announced by both GE and Siemens.

GE (GE Healthcare of Chalfont St. Giles, U.K.) brings us the new Discovery PET/CT 600. I've taken the liberty of reproducing the introductory Flash presentation below:



If you peruse the information (and it takes a little work with this particular Flash construction) you will find a number of nice features, including a 70cm bore, and a table that accomodates patients who are gravitationally challenged at up to 500 lbs. We also have Motion Match motion management, an IBM BladeCenter for fast reconstruction, VUE Point HD lesion detectability, and even PET VCAR efficient treatment assessment, which appears to give one the ability to follow lesions on serial scans much like the MIMVista program. But it is the graphic below that I find rather interesting:


I'm not really sure what this means. I've written before about the differences between Bismuth germinate (BGO), which GE has used for a while and cerium-doped lutetium oxyorthosilicate (LSO), the crystal scintillator used by Siemens for the past several years. However, that article is currently off-line because it refers to some equipment that I am currently using, and I would not wish to offend anyone. The only chart I could find concerning the differences is from Siemens:



Basically, this shows that LSO gives a better response to the anhillation radiation coming out of your patient than BGO. The latter might theoretically be more sensitive, stopping more photons if you will, especially if the crystals are thicker, as the green chart seems to indicate. However, the name of the game is counts, and LSO wins hands-down. Daghighian, et. al., writing in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science in August, 1993, agree:


A new scintillation crystal, cerium doped lutetium oxyorthosilicate (LSO), is discussed. It has light intensity which is 75% of NaI(Tl), scintillation decay time of 12 ns (30%) and 42 ns (70%), effective Z of 66, and density of 7.4 g/cm3. The fast decay time and scintillation light output of LSO are superior to those of bismuth germanate (BGO) for positron emission tomography (PET) and the stopping power of LSO for 511-keV photons is only slightly lower than BGO. The detection characteristics relevant to PET applications of small crystals of LSO (2×2×10 mm) are compared with those of BGO. The energy resolution at 511 keV is 12% full width half maximum (FWHM) for LSO and two to three times wider for BGO. The coincidence timing of two opposing crystals, using a position sensitive photomultiplier tube (PMT), is 1.4 ns FWHM for LSO and more than three times higher for BGO. Using a fast PMT, coincidence timing for LSO yields 0.46 ns FWHM.

Stopping power seems to be analogous to sensitivity in this setting. Why is GE still using the older and less optimal BGO? Maybe Siemens owns the patents for LSO. Now, there is another scintillator in the wings, LYSO, Cerium doped Lutetium Yttrium Orthosilicate, which is as good or better in some ways than LSO. I know GE had been toying with LYSO, but maybe it hasn't yet panned out.

But back to the green graphic. "...potentially reducing the dose requirement and allowing for faster scans and increased throughput..." Ummmm, well, maybe, but it all depends upon the reference value for comparison, doesn't it? I'm not seeing any claims about 5 minute scans here.

I have no details yet on whether the Discovery PET/CT 600 is 2D/3D, although I will assume that it is. Nothing yet on the CT component, either.

Siemens marketing division is apparently composed of '80's throw-backs, as their new ad campaign reads: "I want my mCT!" (OK, maybe you children are too young to remember the old "I want my MTV" slogan.... Just go ahead and rub it in.) It seems that their new offering is too cool to even be called a PET scanner...welcome to the world of molecular CT with the new Biograph mCT. And what else does the "m" indicate?


maximum-return-on-investment CT.
minimum-dosage CT.
more-patient-comfort CT.
meets-every-need CT.
made-for-the-future CT.

Based on the rather detailed brochure, the mCT appears to be a mating of the latest LSO high-resolution PET with the latest Siemens Definition Adaptive Spiral CT. In fact, it's more of a symbiosis than the older Biographs, as the pieces are much more integrated. This is not just a CT and a PET scanner bolted together. From HealthImaging.com:

“This system looks like a CT, feels like a CT, but it has PET embedded within it,” Markus Lusser, VP Global Marketing and Sales, Siemens Medical Solutions Molecular Imaging, told Health Imaging News. “Just by looking at it, you might think it is just CT—you cannot clearly see it has PET at first glance.”The traditional PET-CT approach is to build the PET scanner next to a CT scanner, Lusser said, with about a 6-foot long tunnel. The Biograph mCT, which has approximately a 3-foot long tunnel that is 78 cm wide, and has a 500-pound-capacity bed, is designed to accommodate a variety of patients.

The mCT can be purchased with different slice-counts, from 40 to 120 slices in CT as well as PET features that range from TrueV extended field-of-view technology to ultraHD-PET. “We are offering 128-slice CT configuration which is unmatched in the PET arena,” Lusser said, adding CT scanners dominating the PET-CT arena are mainly 16 slice.

Notice that the bore is 8cm wider than the GE 600, which might cover that last serving of Hagen Das, but the weight-limit is the same. The CT can resolve down to .24mm, although some of the literature says .33mm instead, still pretty small. And, there is attention paid to dose-limitation:

Taking comfort a step further, Biograph mCT addresses two of the foremost concerns related to scanning: scan time and radiation dose. Biograph mCT’s Adaptive Dose Shield protects the patient from unnecessary pre- and post-spiral radiation, conserving 20% dosage in routine CT exams.With its ultra-low dose capability and super-fast PET acquisition time, Biograph mCT gives you everything you need. So scanning can be less stressful for you and your patients.
By "super-fast" they mean a 5 minute PET/CT exam time. That is pretty darn fast.

I may have to get to RSNA this year after all, just to see these two new additions. Of course, it would be nice to be able to actually buy one....

Saturday, October 04, 2008

Some PACS History

David Clunie has a new post on his blog that goes deeper into PACS history. As with many things technical, the US Military spec'ed out some of the early versions, in this case giving us the ancestors of Centricity PACS. This post, and the reproduced RFP itself, is a recommended read for all involved in PACS, and might have been a good resource for various folks in the USPTO.

Has anyone else noticed the explosion of patent-infringement suits in the last few weeks in the medical imaging arena?

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Patently Silly?

My only experience with patents was rather expensive and nonproductive. I invented a device to draw perpendicular lines on a mammogram for needle-localization purposes, which actually was quite elegant. Sadly, after a $500 patent search, I found that I was about the fifth or sixth person to come up with this design. Sigh.

A fan of this blog (thanks to PACSMan and Jennifer) sent me a link to PatentlySilly, a blog about weird patents that really demonstrates just how clueless the US Patent Office can be. Check out this patent for a water-pipe with a little extra stimulus, as a good example. This gets a patent, but my great idea couldn't. There ain't no justice!

There have been several stories lately about DR Systems suing NovaRad, Emageon, and eRad. I first heard about this from an AuntMinnie post, and there has been further elaboration from PACSMan/Ms. PACS and Spidey.

Now, I should state up front that I have met DR Systems President Dr. Murray Reicher, and I continue to correspond with him on non-PACS matters. (I've never even touched a DR product, for better or worse.) In my dealings with him, Dr. Reicher demonstrates the very highest moral and ethical fibre possible, and I don't think his company would pursue patent-infringement lawsuits if he did not feel completely justified in doing so. But I needed to educate myself in the particulars, as this is a very important situation in the PACS world.

The patent in question can be found at the US Patent Office website. The patent, "Automated system and a method for organizing, presenting, and manipulating medical images," was filed by Wesley Hilton, Dr. Reicher, and Dale Seegmiller on December 30, 1992, and approved September 19, 1995. Here is the abstract:


An automated system for organizing, presenting, and manipulating medical images includes a database in which the medical images are structured into groups, each group including one or more image series, each image series including an ordered sequence of images which illustrate incrementally registered aspects of an anatomical target. Image series are presented in their sequential order either in a monitor presentation format which displays each sequence in its entirety in a single monitor display container or which presents two or more image series, image-by-image, in adjacent presentation areas of a series display container. The system includes a plurality of monitors in which all monitors, save one, produce display containers for image series presentation. One monitor is reserved for displaying a working palette to which images of the image series displayed on the other monitors may be moved. The system activates a monitor in a plurality of monitors in response to movement of a cursor between monitors. An active monitor is indicated by presentation of a control panel. The system also provides heads-up presentation of control panel icons at a cursor location outside of the control panel by sequentially changing the shape of the cursor to the icon shapes for user selection.
Got all that? Here's a drawing from the patent that gives you a vague idea of the approach:


Text not available


Feel free to read the entire patent at your leisure. The Summary continues:


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION Therefore, it is a primary objective of this invention to provide an automated system for storage, retrieval, and presentation of medical images which is especially adapted for the presentation of medical image sequences and which affords the user with a flexible and responsive set of functions that permit direct manipulation of the modes of image presentation and of the presented images themselves. The invention is embodied in a computer display system which presents images of anatomical structure and the like for examination. The system includes the following combination: a first display container including a first preselected number of substantially rectangular presentation areas in a substantially rectangular array; a second display container including a second preselected number of substantially rectangular presentation areas in a substantially rectangular array; an image database including a plurality of images of anatomical structure, the images being separated into image groups in which: each image group is indexed by a unique group identification; and each image group is partitioned into one or more ordered image series, each ordered image series including a succession of images which illustrate incrementally registered aspects of an anatomical target, each image series being ordered by assignment to each image in the image series of a position in a respective monotonically changing sequence; a mechanism connected to the image database and to the first and second display container and responsive to a group identification for displaying at least two image series of an image group indexed by the patient identification, wherein: each image series is displayed in the order of its respective sequence in a respective display container such that each presentation area of the respective display container includes no more than one image; or, all of the image series are displayed in one display container and each image series is displayed one image at a time in the order of its respective sequence in a respective presentation area of the display container.
This legalese word salad (there is much more) seems to be discussing what we now call hanging protocols, a preset display configuration for various imaging procedures.

The current lawsuit against Emageon, eRad, and NovaRad was filed in California, and some details can be found here. I actually paid a few dollars to download the complaint itself, which is a public document. Of the fifty-five pages (they only charge $0.08 per page, with maximum charge of thirty pages or $2.40 per document!), the majority simply reproduce the patent in question, 5,452,416, a.k.a, the '416 patent, and this is followed by a series of definitions of the various terms in the patent which come from a prior case against Fuji. The real complaint is succinctly worded, and repeated for the three defendents:


Emageon/eRAD/NovaRad has infringed at least claims 1 and 6 of the '416 patent through, among other activities, the manufacture, use, importation, sale and/or offer for sale of automated medical imaging and archival systems. Emageon/eRAD/NovaRad has also infringed at least claims 1 and 6 of the '416 patent by knowingly and actively inducing others to infringe, and by contributing to the infringement by others.

Hmmmm... Sounds like contributing to the delinquency of a minor. So, we need to look at Claim 1 and Claim 6 of the patent. Here they are:


is to be limited only 10 include all such viewed in conjunction accompanying drawings We claim 1 A system for a location where 15 structure for button of the including the keyboard to the desired location the left button Any appropriate to its default the A icon in executed by annotating a 20 by reference that the of selecting the anatomical sequence of a 25 annotation list commonly employed The procedure an annotation list in the 30 this icon is and is moved in location At the trackball is depressed list to the box 35 panel For so means including one displaying at least display area areas hi a means for storing an of images of being groups hi which each unage group identification each image group ordered unage including a incrementally target each assignment to numerical changing physician data tables unique group

and




series in the order of in a respective display container presentation area of the tainer includes no more than one to designation of the monitor mode 5 The system of claim 1 further means for displaying a palette the one or more display monitors play container for presenting a areas in an array and means for selecting an image of an in the at least one reproducing the selected image area of the palette display 6 A method for presenting structure for examination by a method being executed on a having a display for displaying at least one subdivided into a of Text not available

Well, I'm not a patent attorney, but my semi-educated read of these claims suggests that DR has a point. Pretty much any and all PACS displays could be lumped under this description with enough of a fudge-factor. There does seem to be some specificity for what we would now call a hanging protocol, although a quick read makes it sound like the patent just covers a run-of-the-mill display. That's trouble for everyone else, and good news for DR Systems.

I suppose the moot point her is whether or not DR really invented all this, or at least perfected it. The patent was filed in 1992, and granted in 1995. Was there PACS in 1995? Of course. Were there hanging protocols? Not on the systems I used at that time. Were they in development at other shops? I don't know about that. Moreover, should this sort of thing have been patented? Today, it seems self-evident that you should look at PACS more or less as everyone does it, although I certainly have my own personal preferences in that regard. Is the image layout on the screen patentable? Or copyrightable, for that matter? I've jokingly said that I need to patent both breathing and the sun coming up in the morning; think of the fees I could charge! How much credit does the Patent Office receive for deciding that something should receive a patent? What is a patent anyway? From the Patent Office itself comes the official definition:

. . .a property right granted by the Government of the United States of America to an inventor “to exclude others from making, using, offering for sale, or selling the invention throughout the United States or importing the invention into the United States” for a limited time in exchange for public disclosure of the invention when the patent is granted.

(An invention is) any art or process (way of doing or making things), machine, manufacture, design, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, or any variety of plant, which is or may be patentable under the patent laws of the United States.

You can see that the parameters are pretty nebulous, and an invention is patentable if the USPTO says it is. I guess "breathing" and "sun coming up in the morning" probably won't fly, however. But from Thompson Reuters Scientific comes this list, which is a little more intuitive:

In general a patent will be granted for an invention so long as it:

  • is new or "novel": the invention must never have been made in public in any way, anywhere, before the date on which the application for a patent is filed.
  • involves an inventive or "unobvious" step: this step must not be obvious to others with good knowledge and experience of the subject of the invention.
  • is capable of industrial/useful application: an invention must be capable of being made or used in some kind of industry.
It's the "new" and "unobvious" questions that I cannot answer with respect to the DR programs. The way patent applications are written, chock full of legalese and mumbo jumbo, nothing is obvious. Is the layout of images on a screen obvious, new, and unique? Is the concept of hanging protocols obvious? Was it new and unique in 1992? I'll have to leave that to folks older and wiser than I. I could barely spell PACS back then. But, we do have the reality of the patent granted to DR at that time.

DR has sued other PACS vendors, and several small companies have settled. Supposedly, some larger companies are considering fighting DR Systems, which to my non-legal mind would require invalidation of the DR '416 patent. I'm not sure that would be easy, and I know it would be incredibly expensive. The lawyers always win, don't they?

Ironically, DR Systems has itself been sued by GE for patent infringement. A suit filed by GE in the US District Court of the Eastern District of New York on 10/16/2006 notes:

DR Systems has been and now is directly infringing and indirectly infringing, by way of inducement and contribution, the '674 Patent in this district and elsewher in the US by making, using, selling, and offering for sale image and information management systems for hospitals and medical imaging centers that practice one or more claims of the '674 Patent. The infringing systems include the Catapult Technologist QC Workstation, Advanced Windows Catapult, The Dominator, Web Dominator, The Instant Reporter, Web Ambassador, CD Ambassador, The Communicator, and/or Guardian Archive.

DR Systems' actions have damaged GE in an amount to be determined at trial and have caused and will continue to cause GE irreparable injury for which GE has no adequate remedy at law.

Sounds kind of familiar, doesn't it? Here we go again...

GE's Patent 6,633,674 was filed November 25, 1999, and issued October 14, 2003. Here is Claim 1:

1. A picture archiving and communication system comprising:
an input device configured to receive uncompressed medical image data files including a descriptive header and image data, and to convert each of the uncompressed image data files to a hybrid compressed data file including uncompressed descriptive header data, compression header, and compressed image data;
a data file server coupled to the input device for storing the hybrid compressed image data files;
a client system coupled to the server, the client system being configured to receive the hybrid compressed data files and to uncompress the image data for output; and
a database accessible by the file server for referencing the hybrid compressed data files.
The rest of the claims have more to do with compression. Here again, a semi-educated read makes it sound like GE has patented PACS, doesn't it? I didn't go through all the court documents (even at $0.08 per page, the cost adds up, you know!) but the suit was eventually dropped "with prejudice."

I think the bottom line here is that the Patent Office granted a lot of patents for PACS and related technologies, almost certainly without completely understanding all the vagarities and implications of what they were approving. I'm sure I don't grasp it all, and I really doubt that anyone does. DR's suits based on Patent '416 seem to me to have some validity, based on the existence of the patent itself. As I noted above, the lawyers win no matter what.

Addendum: Aunt Minnie's Brian Casey has written about this topic as well, and has gone more in depth about the claims of the initial patent.

Saturday, September 27, 2008

Hollywood House Recycling?


Being a good husband sometimes means seeing movies you might have otherwise avoided. Today, I took my wife to see the consumate chick-flick weeper, "Nights in Rodanthe." I won't give away the plot, but suffice it to say, it lives up (or down) to its reputation.

The action takes place mostly in Rodanthe, which is on Hatteras Island in the Outer Banks of North Carolina. When the main scene of the inn on the beach appeared, I nudged my wife and said, "That sure looks like the Weasley's house in the Harry Potter movies!" She gave me the "shut up and watch the movie, you unfeeling lump" look in response.

Anyway, I found a photo of the Weasley's house, which was called "The Burrow" in the Harry Potter movies, as well as a shot of the house used for "Nights in Rodanthe". One in the same? Well, the ocean is apparently encroaching further and further upon the Rodanthe house, and maybe it too is only held up by magic these days.

Friday, September 26, 2008

Buttons, Buttons, and More Buttons


Shuttle controls, image courtesy of http://www.nasa.gov

I've done you the favour of reproducing the "Customization" window from one of our larger PACS installations. You may have to click on the image to see the details. Depicted below is the window that allows us to change the tools on the toolbar and on the "context", or the right-click menu.



This particular screen capture shows how we change the settings for the "CRDX" modality. A drop-down gives you access to changing the other modalities. Our list has 29 modalities, although we probably actually access about 10 of these. Now, given that there are 89 tools, which can either be present or absent, each modality can have 2^89, or 6.1897002 × 10^26 available tool arrangements, so with 29 modalities, we therefore have 9.08696418 × 10^776 possibilities. OK, we don't use all the modalities, as I admitted, and if you look closely at the tools, many relate to digital mammography, and some are different facets of tools that are usually combined, such as "Flip Horizontal", "Flip Vertical", and the "Rotate" clusters. Moreover, I won't ever use a significant number of these functions. But that still leaves us with millions and millions of possible configurations.

To add to the joy of this particular product's setup, each modality has its own "Screen Layout" control, with all these options:



The little bar of 5 screens can be preset, but this is all you can access from within the viewer itself. Most other products give full control from a much simpler button or pair of buttons on the viewer:


To add further to our joy, there is a complete palette for digital mammo controls:




Buttons, buttons, buttons.

I've bemoaned this sort of thing for years, as my regular readers know quite well. Give me a streamlined package that lets me do my job without this level of distraction. So how did we get to this mess, and how do we get out of it? I discussed this with my friend and guru, PACS Ferret, whom I stole from the big U down the road, and he set me straight on a few things. There are stark differences in the way things are done in academia and in private practice. I view myself as more or less typical of a private practice PACS user. I need to power through my studies with the greatest accuracy and the least distraction possible. In the academic world, a place I haven't visited for quite a while, much time is taken for teaching, and research. The cases are often pre-read by residents. Some of those obscure tools might have a place.

This explains to some degree where all the tools came from. Some site calls up the vendor and said, "we need a left-handed spanner," and Shazam, there it is on the desktop. This might work well here and there, but if the solution to creating a GUI is to give the suckers what they want, everything any one of them might want, you end up with the astronomical number of control permutations (or is that combinations?) calculated above. There has to be a better way.

The solution to this mess is multi-factoral. First, send me $700 Billion, and then I'll.... Oh, wait, wrong mess. No, first, there needs to be a cleanup of sorts, with consolidation of multiple duplicate or near-duplicate functions, and more intelligent design overall. But beyond this, there may well need to be a whole new approach. PACS Ferret suggests a modular approach. There could be plug-ins or entire modules devoted to certain audiences. Perhaps the mammography module would include all the important tools for this modality. The academic version could include every tool known, including a picture-in-picture window to monitor the residents and see if they are goofing off. The private practice version would be streamlined, of course, but could have modules for high-level visualization as required, be they for cardiac imaging, virtual colongraphy, or whatever. I'm suggesting that these components blend in seamlessly with the PACS GUI, rather than spawn as add-on programs as we often see today.

With the modular approach, one PACS could be made to fit all, much more easily than what we see today. Of course, this doesn't address the functionality of the GUI itself, which is a related but different story.

You can never be too rich or too thin (that one has been disproven, by the way), but you certainly can have too many buttons. There are ways to keep this under control, which some vendors understand and some don't. However, I have to realize that there are those rads out there who probably want some of the things I consider superfluous, so we need to find a way to accommodate them. Throwing in everything but the kitchen sink on every version just won't cut it, but maybe, just maybe, the modular approach could keep your sink out of my playground.

Addendum:

One of my friends from the large PACS company above told me about the "CNTL-Right Click" text menu of tools:



Having used the program for several years now, I had no idea this existed. Maybe I need to do a CNTL-SHIFT-Right-Click and see if that brings out some Easter Egg or maybe wipes the disk.

This "new" approach is slightly helpful to access a tool that I might use once a year. I will have already organized my Right-Click tools to include those I use the majority of the time.

Another Addendum

A representative from a big PACS company had this to say about my post:

There is no doubt that many PACS vendors continue to carry the sins of the past (90's) in which tools were added at a single request, but with maturity of products and the market expectation, I believe that we see far more constraint these days when considering tools. For instance, does the tool meet the needs of more then one user, how can that outcome be achieved within the context of an existing tool etc. . I could discuss with you the analysis done to actually determine tool usage across (hundreds of) installations and you would feel justified in your opinion, given the 10-90 rule (10 % of tools are used 90% of the time) However, from my perspective, the blog was a bit misleading because it failed to set any type of control in the example picture, that complex library of tools shown can be controlled via proviledges, that once set, reduce the 'plethora of tools" the user sees, That window was that the "ALL tools" window for general management versus the tabbed libraries which focus on specific toolsets. The control RMB was put in place to allow users to set minimal icon based menus but still have acess to other tools that are needed on occaision. This will in theory also reduce the need to edit the menu as often? My point...

Respectfully, I agree with your overall assessment, but feel that it doesnt necessarily reflect newer/emerging products that have learnt from the sins of the past. We PACS vendors are trying to get smarter by listening instead of thinking.

And indeed I'm finding this to be the case. The change is slow, but sure.

London's PACS Is Falling Down

It seems that London (Ontario, not that other London) has a little problem. According to the London Free Press,

London and area doctors are being asked to carefully select which patients need X-rays after the $50-million digital system serving eight hospitals was partially crippled during a weekend computer upgrade.
London's hospitals have brought in more staff and reverted to using X-ray film, a technology they left behind five years ago when they switched to the new system.

London's two hospitals share the system with hospitals in Ingersoll, Strathroy, Newbury, St.Thomas, Tillsonburg, Woodstock, Stratford, Goderich, Exeter, St. Marys, Seaforth and Clinton.

Oops. Just in case you were interested, Hewlett Packard supplied the hardware, and.....
HP teamed on the project with GE Healthcare, a major provider of transformational medical technologies, and Cerner Corp., a leading supplier of healthcare information technology. GE Healthcare is providing the picture archiving and communication system (PACS) and Cerner is providing its Cerner Millennium® platform for electronic patient records and radiology.

Sorry. Hope it gets fixed quickly. Many thanks to Miss Pat for the tip.

Sunday, September 21, 2008

PACS State-Of-The-Art, Circa 1985


PACS has existed in some form or another for quite a while. Today, we are rather jaded with the multitude of options out there. Do we go with Windows or Linux or Unix for the back end? Do we use 2 MP flat-panel monitors, or 3 MP or even 5 MP's? Gigabit Ethernet to the desktop is a given in most places, so in-house transmission times are almost negligible. And so it goes.

There was a time, however, when this was almost science fiction, and the assemblage of disparate components into what we call a PACS was the goal of a handful of visionaries around the world.

Long before my trip to UCSF to visit Bernie Huang in 1992, as described in a previous post, there were a number of centers developing functioning digital departments. I recently stumbled across an article from the University of Kansas by Arch Templeton, M.D., Samuel Dwyer, Ph.D, et. al., documenting such an effort.
Looking back, the problems of film seem almost funny today:

In most radiology departments, digitally formatted radiographic information is recorded, used, and stored as analog images on multiformat film, manually assembled in individual patient jackets and retained in a central film file. . . Sequential (one at a time) access to film jackets results in limiting the diagnostic information to one user or display site at a time.

And the solution?
The solution is a peripheralized (not centralized) computer based system that can capture, display and archive all digitally formatted image and alphanumeric data generated during a patient's hospital stay. The system must have on-line access, fast communication links, and high utilization capabilities. It must be bidirectionally integrated to an appropriate long term archiving system.
Here is what they envisioned, and ultimately built:



The interesting historical note here is that the system was indeed built as a series of nodes, with relatively independent architecture. Contrast that to today's PACS with a central web-style arrangement. For long-term storage, there were various options, including magnetic tape, or magnetic disks. The old Winchester-type sealed disks were available in 450 MB capacity for about $15,000 per drive, or one could splurge on a 1GB drive for $130,000! Other options included optical disks ($8,000 for the drive, $150 for the 4GB disk). There was such a thing as linear optical tape (drive cost: $80,000-$100,000, 50GB tape reel cost: $2500). The article even discusses laser-sensitive x-ray film which could store 1MB/cm2, or 238 MB on a 14 x 17 sheet!

We've definately come a long way, baby.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Radiology Sales

Sometimes good ideas come in pairs, or even in threes. I've introduced you to PACS-aholic, the new blog from the PACSman and Ms. PACS, designed to give us an inside look at the PACS industry. In today's entry, Mike and Cristen give the PACS sales institution a well-deserved kick in the pants, with some well-justified finger-pointing. This should be required reading for anyone who has even the slightest connection with purchasing a PACS.

I've discovered a new blog that could possibly blow the lid off of radiology sales practices. "Spidey" apparently knows something about this, and his (her?) blog, SPIDEYKNOWS_SALES (http://spideyknows.blogspot.com/), promises to deliver "tales from the streets and rooftops about winning and losing in selling to the Radiology marketplace." "Spidey" is a salesperson, who has been successful at the game, and still likes what he does. Why? "Because I like to win. I like to solve problems and I like to see people have the tools to enable them to do their job better." My kind of sales person; I haven't met too many like him.

"Spidey's" first post is, to put it bluntly, a hatchet-job on the gang-approach to sales, slashing the common practice of bringing everyone from a low-level VP to a low level janitor along for the VISIT to the CLIENT. But Spidey also places some blame on the customer where it is due:
Yet, some clients even demand it...they feel insulted if a "herd" doesn't arrive, because don't numbers indicate how important one is? I wonder how far prices could be reduced and profits increased if vendors and potential clients would focus on learning about solving a problem from the best person capable of solving it? Cut the number of mouths on the Commission food chain and compensate the person or person(s) who go out in the morning and bring supper on the table at night.
And this is what I've been saying in some form for a while. I've been wined and dined over the years, I've been visited by the "herd" and I've been taken on some great junkets. Ten years ago, Elscint took me and a partner to Israel and Germany to look at some new developments in MRI. We flew Business Class, stayed in the finest hotels, and had ample time for touring, at Elscint expense. The irony here is that Elscint's MRI division was purchased the week before we went on this little trip by. . . GE. So, I had a really good time at you-know-who's expense. The bigger irony is that Elscint (and subsequently GE) never even produced more than one or two prototypes of the machines we demoed. Tens of thousands of sales dollars shot to hell. And in many ways, this trip was a little more justified than most, as this was the only way to see what these one-of-a-kind machines could do. But a web-based PACS can be demoed anywhere, anytime, without the entire entourage of suits and accouterments. There needs to be a new paradigm in this industry, with more conscientious investment of time and money directed where it should go, and not toward some administrator, IT-type, or physician's ego. Just show me the machine. Since no one has listened to me on this topic, maybe Mike, Cristen, or Spidey will have better luck.

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Questions From ANOTHER Interaction Designer

Another anonymous PACS designer chimes in:

I'm an interaction designer/programmer as well. And I find Cooper & Reimann's book Interaction Design 2.0 to be useful in educating programmers about generic user expectations and behavior. It also introduces some important concepts which we use in our design guidance documents.

As much as I agree about the importance of good interaction design, market forces are such that what people pay for (from among what is offered) is what the market will provide more of. So I have some questions related to that.

1) When purchasing a PACS, how do radiologists evaluate the software interaction? To what extent are they willing to try out unfamiliar(but possibly better) interaction models, and how much time are they willing to give to that process?

2) Does anyone evaluate the ease of use of anything besides the radiologist's workstation? If so, what?

3) How much is usability weighted in the purchase decision? And how much of a premium (in purchase price) is a superior design worth?

Very good questions, all. Here, we really get to the crux of the matter, whether a more usable product is a sales advantage, and worth more than Brand X.


Now, I can answer all of these according to my own, biased, radiologist-centric viewpoint, which might not be accurate for all involved. Based on my experience and research and observation, it is probably rare for the radiologists to actually decide which PACS to buy. As often as not, the choice lies in the hands of bean-counters, and/or the IT folks, who may or may not pay attention to the needs, wants, desires, and whines of the radiologists.


So, how do radiologists evaluate the software interaction from a 10-minute demo? Very poorly. It is impossible to see how a complex piece of software will behave in your hands in that short a time. In most cases, the sales or apps person is "driving" anyway, and we poor rads get no hands-on time at all. From this brief exposure, we are supposed to make a million-dollar decision. I have long advocated prolonged web-based demos, and I still think they represent the best approach.


When I'm looking at new software, I try to use it as if I were actually in a production environment. This isn't easy, especially in a 10-minute demo, but it can and should be done. Now, trying new processes is a problem. I, for one, am willing to do so, but some are not. If the keys to the "new process" are not immediately obvious, if it is not intuitive, it will be bypassed.


Let me go off on a tangent for a moment. I received a disk from St. Elsewhere over the weekend with a client program from a smaller PACS company. The damn thing loaded VERY slowly, and the GUI was esoteric. I was actually in the middle of writing a hatchet-piece about the program in between call cases. However, the more I worked with the viewer in the process of digging up dirt on it, the more I found it useful, or put another way, the less I hated it. Thus, unfamiliarity in this business breeds contempt. Now, this particular program will never reach the level of Dalai-usability, but it wasn't quite as bad as I first thought. There is a balance, a threshold of what works well for all immediately, and what will eventually work better than you think it will initially.


How much time will we give to checking out something new? Probably not enough. Again, we need to see quickly that your new process is better than the old way.

Hopefully, PACS admins and IT types are allowed to look at the back-end of the system as well as the front. The best GUI in the world is useless if its underpinnings don't work well. The support folks need to be checking out the administrative tools, ease of fixing studies, and ten dozen other things that I couldn't even begin to name. Yes, I do indeed acknowledge their importance!

The part usability plays in the purchase goes right back to who is really in charge. If the rads ignore the job of selection, and just depend on the proverbial "someone else" to do the picking, then it probably doesn't matter at all. The same is true if the rads are excluded from the decision altogether. (It happens, trust me.)

And it needs to be stated that usability is in the eyes (and mouse) of the beholder. One of my senior partners proclaimed for the first time yesterday that he vastly prefers Agfa Impax 6 to Amicas LightBeam. Why? Because with Impax, you can access the ruler tool via the right-click menu, and with LightBeam, you have to scoot the mouse up to the tool-bar. The other features (no matter how well or poorly done) don't matter to him one bit, at least they didn't yesterday. Now, my other 27 partners think just the opposite, but you see the dilemma. Whom should the designers target? Why me, of course!

How much is a good design worth? That's somewhat of a trick question. In the PACS business, there is a significant disconnect between price and design. I don't have to go there again, do I? Designing a program that actually works properly in the hands of real users might well cost more that just letting the engineers/designers/programmers run loose. There should be numerous iterations of redesign and retesting with real live radiologists, especially those who do not already use the company's product. That's a hard process to quantify and deciding what it's really worth is even harder.

I've been preaching about GUI design for years and years. It's nice to see the concept finally get some attention, and I really appreciate hearing from the guys on the front lines in this effort. Will their hard work pay off? It should! The better, more usable PACS should sell better than the clunker, but that may not work so well in the real world, where IT may decide to purchase from the company that "no one ever gets fired for chosing," whichever that might be this week. But keep up the good work guys; sooner or later someone WILL be fired for picking an unusable system. Someday. I promise.

Friday, September 12, 2008

Further Down The Green Brick Road


As a Centricity user, I have wondered how the "Centricitgrad" integration is progressing. As I still have friends at GE (well, they used to work for DI, but...), I was able to get the official inside scoop:
It has been 11 months since GE Healthcare acquired Dynamic Imaging, and operationalized their business within GE as “Dynamic Imaging Solutions”. Since the announcement, both Centricity PACS, and Centricity PACS-IW (formerly Dynamic Imaging’s IntegradWeb PACS) have both enjoyed success in the marketplace – gaining healthy shares in the various market segments.

While Dynamic Imaging Solutions continues to operate as a separate business unit within GE Healthcare IT’s Imaging Solutions division, the fruits of the consolidated, global engineering efforts are already showing significant progress.

GE is leveraging and integrating a number of technologies (i.e., PACS-IW Web client technology, RealTimeImaging’s advanced streaming technology, previously acquired by IDX/GE), to provide a powerful, Web accessible, diagnostic capable viewer that communicates directly with the robust Centricity PACS infrastructure. At GE’s user group conference, the GE Healthcare User Summit in Washington , D.C last month, 13 customers experienced a preview of our work-in-progress (WIP) and provided invaluable feedback to our product mangers and engineers. The response was very positive, as the new capabilities and diagnostic workflow will benefit radiologists as well as many major clinical areas.

The formal product reveal, currently a WIP, will require FDA 510K clearance prior to release due to the interpretive capabilities of the viewer. GE is excited about our great progress and customer feedback thus far. Our next steps are the clinical pilots, with culmination of our 2008 activities at RSNA in Chicago .
I always thought IntegradWeb had good streaming capabilities, but perhaps they have been improved. I guess we'll see more come RSNA.

Tuesday, September 09, 2008

OK, Now Agfa Isn't For Sale

I've been reporting on and off for a while that Agfa was trying to sell off its healthcare division. Today, Agfa said, "Not so fast..."

From Reuters:

BRUSSELS, Sept 9 (Reuters) - Belgian imaging technology group Agfa-Gevaert (AGFB.BR: Quote, Profile, Research, Stock Buzz) said on Tuesday it planned to keep its healthcare unit together and that its board had not launched a process to sell the operation.

The company referred to a number of media articles in recent weeks stating that Agfa was set to start a formal sales process of healthcare.

"In its regular meeting of today, September 9, 2008, the board of directors has taken note of the confusion created by this misleading information and therefore has decided to set the record straight," Agfa said in a statement.

Belgian daily De Standaard for example reported last Friday that Agfa was taking steps to sell the unit by the end of this year, driving Agfa shares up by some 5 percent.

"The board confirms that no decision has been taken to launch a process for the sale of the healthcare business group," Agfa said, adding its priority was to improve operational efficiency.

"The board confirms its commitment to the preservation of the unity of the healthcare business group, to its strategy and to the investments made for extending its leading position in healthcare IT," it continued.

Agfa, which specialises in imaging systems, IT and top-end printers for publishers and newspapers, had planned last year to split into three separately listed companies -- Agfa Graphics, Agfa Health Care and Agfa Materials.

It scrapped the plan after disappointing first-quarter results, saying the move was no longer viable. . .

Analysts believe healthcare is the unit Agfa would most likely spin off or sell, although the company first needs to address problems there.

I stand ready to help address those problems if called upon to do so.

Saturday, September 06, 2008

A Note From An Interaction Designer


On occasion, someone actually believes me to be wise in matters pertaining to PACS. It's amazing how far you can get on self-promotion.

Anyway, I've been working with several companies on their PACS designs, taking great care to avoid any cross-talk. Today, I received the email below from one company:

A request for your thoughts. . . You're unique in that you have notoriety in the medical imaging world, and actually have advocated for the need for interaction design. . . .

I am the interaction designer who works on user research and interaction design; as well as working with programmers to actually try to get the designs built. My goal is to make physicians happy and fully engaged in their software, or at least get rid of some of the "grr" :)

The questions I have for you:

1) How much of what you (or the average "Joe" rad persona) cares about in a PACS system is in the interaction design (behavior/workflow) and visual design?

2) Do you think other vendors have picked up on having dedicated interaction designers? I wonder what our best competitors are doing. If they don't call it interaction design, do they have people continually focusing on users and the user interface, planing the workflow of a user through the interface toward his goals rather than on how to architect-build-code-program the user interface?

3) How effective are seeing designs in giving you a sense of the final user experience (and workflow)? The intention of the this early review is always deeper understanding to fix on an initial plan of what to build (a design); that design is then built in software and can be tested out by rads hands-on. Having users try out an iPod is the best way to make alterations to the iPod experience, but you need to design an iPod in the first place, and not a Zune or worse a Sandisk player (I hate the Sandisk, the buttons change meaning on each level of navigation argh! Impossible to use, a pure waste of $45).

Wow. I have notoriety! Is that sort of like credibility? Oh well....

If you have a look at my old post, The Inmates Are Running The Asylum, you will see more or less where I'm coming from. Alan Cooper, of Cooper Designs, promotes the concept of software tailored for the user, and not simply cobbled together by the coders/programmers, the "inmates of the asylum".

Cooper designs interactive products that deliver power and pleasure to the people who use them. Our design methodology is founded on the observation that people will gladly use and recommend products that are designed to advance their goals, while they dislike products that merely satisfy feature checklists or are informed solely by abstract notions of simplicity.

Cooper’s Goal-Directed design methodology places the goals of the user at the center of the design process. Rather than focusing exclusively on underlying technologies or the tasks that users must perform to use their current products, our process identifies what it is that users want to accomplish in the first place and results in designs that satisfy those goals.

Thoroughly understanding the environments in which people use products, and determining the goals they expect to accomplish, yields designs that deliver a satisfying customer experience. Goal-Directed design delivers power to users without intimidating them and guards against the development of products that lack features and affordances essential to the satisfaction of users. Conversely, Goal-Directed design also prevents the addition of features that, however clever, are rarely used or irrelevant to core goals of the product users

There is a major PACS product that was revamped with the help of Cooper Design. Sadly, no one appears to have actually listened to Cooper's advice that must have cost them hundreds of thousands, if not millions to obtain. The result of the interaction was a "prettier" product which was far more esoteric and harder to use than its predecessor.

But let me answer the questions. First, how much of what I care about in a PACS is in the interaction, etc.? Are you kidding me? Is this a trick question? You could say that the images are the most important thing, and of course, that is the purpose of the PACS, to show me those images. Every single PACS out there, from the very worst to the very best, from free open-source software to the most expensive gold-plated diamond-encrusted magnum opus extravaganza will do that. The ONLY differentiating feature IS the interaction design! I guess this is one of those universal truths that is so very fundamental that it is not as obvious as it should be.

What makes one PACS easy to use and another difficult? It is the consideration of the user's needs, the interaction design as Cooper calls it, and perhaps to a bit lesser degree the visual design, the skin if you will. The designer (in general, this should NOT be the same guy that writes the code, although I know a few folks in the business that excel at both) needs to see how the radiologist will use the program, and make that interaction smooth and easy. I have said in numerous posts that the PACS shouldn't get in my way, and that is perhaps the simplest explanation of how to design it. This doesn't just happen; the program has to be written such that the images are easily available, and amenable to whatever manipulation is needed for their interpretation. Like a fine automobile connects you to the road, PACS connects you to the images. When driving, your focus should be on the road, and the car should allow you to make that connection without demanding so much of your attention that you become dangerous. When reading imaging studies, PACS should let you focus on the patient, without superflous controls or buttons, or sliders, or tabs, or whatever. Distracting me from the images can be rather dangerous to the patient, and profitable for the litigators.

In essence, PACS IS the workflow, it IS the interaction. I care about this. A lot.

Have other vendors figured this out? Yes, to varying extents. No one seems to call it interaction design, but then Cooper's influence may not be all that wide-spread. But those systems that have won my admiration definately zero-in on my interface goals. Do they have people that focus on users and interfaces? Yes, they do. Some of them do the coding, some don't, but all of them understand that the damn thing is being written to facilitate radiologists interpreting images. Such a simple concept.

The design reviews referred to above certainly do help. Like my friend's example of the iPod vs. the Sandisk player, having a functioning framework for testing is certainly one of the best ways to see what works and what doesn't. I can't really think of a better way to do this. You have to see how your model performs in the hands of the users doing with it what they do every day. A focus-group or questionnaire won't get you very far in the real world.

It's sort of ironic that my friend hates his Sandisk because the buttons change meaning on each level of navigation. Kind of like screens toggling in a state-dependent manner isn't it? Arrrggghhh is right!

I don't have a handle on what the rest of the radiologists in the world think about the various interface issues, but I know what works for me. I have said a number of times that Amicas has come close to figuring this out, and they have done so by listening to their users, perhaps more than many other companies. Creating a great PACS is simple if you follow this simple recipe. Lots of happiness, little "grrrrrr".

How much of what I care about in a PACS system is in the interaction design (behavior/workflow) and visual design? A heck of a lot. But then I've been saying that for a long time, in my quest for notoriety.

Wednesday, September 03, 2008

Blog Competition!


I've been talking with Mike Cannavo for years about blogging. He kept threating to start his own blog, while I kept urging him to ghost-write for me, or at least contribute outright to my illustrious blog. Well, he has finally gone off the deep end with his very own site, so allow me to introduce you to PACS-aholic, "An intoxicating look at the PACS industry".

Mike is not going it alone, unlike your intrepid Dalai. No, he will be working with "Ms. PACS":
Now for the true identity of Ms. PACS - underneath the smoke and mirrors, Ms. PACS is Cristen C. Bolan, the Editor of Imaging Technology News (ITN) magazine. ITN is read by Radiologists and Radiation Oncologists who want the latest news on technology for the hospital and outpatient space.
Mike, of course, is no slouch himself (posture non-withstanding):
You may already be familiar with the notorious PACS guru - the PACSman. Michael J. Cannavo earned his reputation as the PACSman for his more than 22 years of experience advising healthcare facilities and providers on the essentials of PACS in the healthcare enterprise.
Mike may be best known for his series of "Exploring PACS Secrets" on AuntMinnie.com, and PACS-aholic promises to extend the expose' into new and uncharted territory. The blog takes the point-counterpoint format as seen in the Weekend Update segments of Saturday Night Live, wherein Dan Aykroyd would respond to Jane Curtin by calling her an ignorant . . . well, you know. Fortuately, Mike and Cristen are much more civil.

Being sort of a PACS-aholic myself, I'm looking forward to some great information and entertainment. Good luck, and welcome to the blogosphere, kids!

Monday, September 01, 2008

Desperately Seeking Updates


I hope everyone has had a happy and enjoyable Labor Day weekend. Sadly, it's now time to think about going back to the regular grind, you know, work. There is indeed a reason why work is a four-letter word.
I really don't mind going back after a long weekend, although when I've been off for one week, or more rarely two, it's a bit harder. And part of the joy is my realization that depending upon the site to which I'm assigned on that black Monday, I will have to wrestle with one balky PACS or another to accomplish my tasks for the day.
As I'm not interested in generating trouble for anyone in the form of letters from acronymical government agencies, I will avoid the pleasure of naming names and repetitively repeating lists of problems. But it seems some of the problems we are having with one of our systems are fixed by an update that came out a long time ago. However, on many PACS, adding updates can be a real pain that has the potential to shut down the enterprise. Thus, in the interest of avoiding yet another trip to the servers, we decided to wait for the update that was supposed to be available this January. Ah, but alas, here it is September 1st, and this wonderful update that fixed even more stuff is nowhere to be seen. And why is this? Well, the only word that has filtered down to my peon level is that the company has been adding more features to this update to satisfy various customers.
How should we feel about this turn of events? In my bowel-unrest over this situation, I have to conclude that the update process for many if not most companies is broken. Waiting this period of time for critical fixes is unacceptable, but there doesn't seem to be a way to get anything but an absolutely critical, emergency, life-saving patch out the door in any reasonable amount of time. This might have something to do with the way the code is written or managed. Perhaps there is a more modular approach that would allow the repair of one section without tearing apart another? That's beyond my expertise, but maybe I'm somewhere near the right track?
And, there needs to be a much better method of deployment. Updates should not be major events that are life-threatening to the PACS staff (who are in danger from the radiologists if they can't get the system back up in 5 minutes). Why is it that even horrible bloatware like Windows can automatically update in the background, but PACS server software can't? I know that some companies use a three server configuration, including the main production server, a test server, and a fail-over server. While it is still a pain to update with this system, the whole thing doesn't crumble during the process, we don't have to point to different servers during the update, etc. There has got to be a better way.
Finally, in our particular situation, the blame for the rather long delay in the update is laid at the feet of the customers (might be us, but I don't think it is) who are demanding new and different functionality. I'm assuming these requests are coming from existing customers; if the additions are for potential customers, well, let's just say Hell hath no fury like a Dalai scorned, and someone better be ready to take one for the team.
Lemme give every company out there a big hint: FIX what's wrong with what's out there BEFORE you start adding NEW thing that will break. I don't think that's a radical concept.
So, I'm begging PACS vendors to consider this request: Put some work into your update process. And your updates. And the rest of your software, as needed. It would be most appreciated.
I'll be sure to, ummmm, update everyone when I see some progress. Enjoy the rest of Labor Day!